A modest newly built gray home with a sheltered porch and light snow on the lawn in a quiet Michigan neighborhood.

Where to Find a New Home Inside Allegan's City Limits This Winter

November 19, 2026

Two finished houses on North Sherman Street are the quickest way into a new home inside Allegan's city limits. 367 North Sherman is listed at $289,900. It has 1,798 square feet, three bedrooms, two and a half baths and a two-car garage. A few doors away, 346 North Sherman is listed at $299,900 for 2,083 square feet and five bedrooms. Both are part of River Ridge Village, Allen Edwin Homes' 42-home site condominium at 500 Delano Street.

If you build one of those same floorplans from scratch, the price starts higher. Allen Edwin's River Ridge Village page lists the to-be-built versions from $329,900 to $364,900, covering the same 1,798 to 2,083 square feet. In Allegan right now, the new homes that cost the least are the ones already built. Everything else the city has in motion is rental housing, a single lot, or land that has been approved and rezoned but isn't selling homes yet. If you're comparing Allegan with Otsego, Plainwell or Kalamazoo County and want new construction, River Ridge Village is the decision you can actually make this winter.

River Ridge Village is the for-sale supply

The city's October 2024 approval materials describe River Ridge Village as detached single-family homes in bi-level and two-story designs, organized as a site condominium. The homes are sold to individual buyers. The community has a homeowners association, so ask about dues and rules early in any conversation about a lot here. By June 2025 the development was under construction. City Manager Joel Dye mentioned it that month in a council memo about a different project. He wrote that neighbors raised density, traffic and utility concerns about that project, and that the city had heard similar concerns when the Allen Edwin homes off Delano Street were approved.

Matched by size, the finished homes are listed $40,000 to $65,000 below the floorplan prices: the 1,798-square-foot home by $40,000 and the 2,083-square-foot home by $65,000. Both quick move-ins also carry a 5.5% promotional rate, shown on the builder's page at 6.278% APR. In our view, that pricing lines up with what the wider county market is doing this fall.

The county market is giving buyers room

The West Michigan Lakeshore Association of Realtors counted 302 active listings in Allegan County in October 2026, up 11% from October 2025. Over the same month the county's median sale price was $340,000, down 6.2% year over year. September was similar. The September 2026 median was $360,000, down 5.3% from a year earlier, and active listings were up 7.4%. Homes sold in October 2026 spent an average of 30 days on the market, so sellers who price well still sell within a month.

These are countywide figures from the lakeshore association's MLS, so treat the median as a broad benchmark, not a direct comparison for a house a few blocks from the Kalamazoo River. Even so, River Ridge's finished homes are listed well under that county figure, and its build-to-order plans start below it.

Rates explain why the promo matters. WMLAR's October 2026 report cites Freddie Mac's national average 30-year rate of 7.24% as of October 29, 2026, compared with 6.17% a year earlier. A builder rate a point and a half below the national average changes the monthly payment more than a few thousand dollars off the price would. Promotional rates come with terms and expire, so this is general information and not financial advice. Confirm current terms with the builder's lender and compare them with an independent loan officer before you count on them.

The next homes for sale are on the old Girl Scout property

The next owner-occupied homes in the city are planned for the former Girl Scout property. That's about 14.55 acres of city-owned land west of the Wolcott, Riverside and Highland neighborhood, close to the Kalamazoo River. The city agreed to sell it to Allegan Development Co. for $100,000. The developer plans 26 condominiums and 12 townhomes, 38 homes in all.

The project has come back to the city several times since mid-2025:

  1. July 14, 2025: on reconsideration, the council approved the purchase and development agreement 5–2.
  2. October 20, 2025: the Planning Commission unanimously recommended the planned unit development. Four speakers opposed it and one supported it.
  3. November 10, 2025: Ordinance 532, the rezoning to a planned unit development, came before the council, and Wilcox Newspapers covered the 38-home plan and the learning lab.
  4. December 22, 2025: the council voted 7–0 to approve a lot split and 7–0 to approve an amendment to the agreement.

The plan puts the homes on the higher ground and leaves the lower land along the river to the Allegan Conservation District for an outdoor learning lab. In July 2026, the council voted 7–0 to approve a brownfield plan for parcels at Babylon Road, Highland Road and Wolcott Street, in the same corner of town.

For a buyer, the two projects are different products. River Ridge Village sells detached houses at listed prices today. The Girl Scout site is planned as condos and townhomes near the river. These two projects are the only for-sale new construction in the city's pipeline, and they don't compete for the same buyer.

Most of what the city is adding next is rental

Most of Allegan's other new housing is apartments, and a lot of it sits on land or in buildings the city owns or helped pay for.

On Lowe Street, the city approved a sale and development agreement with Woda Cooper for an affordable apartment building. In June 2026, the state announced a $1,476,000 low-income housing tax credit award for the project, called Allegan Terrace. Woda Cooper Development and KZR Properties are the sponsors, and the plan is 44 one- and two-bedroom apartments for households at 30%, 40% and 80% of area median income.

Downtown, the council accepted a letter of intent in August 2025 for a $1.18 million state Community Development Block Grant toward ten second-floor apartments. Four are at 116 Locust, two at 115 Locust, two at 138 Hubbard and two at 145 Brady. Wilcox Newspapers reported a total project cost of $1.58 million, with six of the units set aside for households at or below 80% of area median income. These apartments are above the same Locust and Hubbard storefronts that got busier this year, as we covered in our post on downtown Allegan's first season on the rebuilt blocks.

The smallest project is one house. ND Community Partners proposed the "North & Main Infill Residence" on a city-owned parcel at North and Main Streets. It's a 1,056-square-foot home with two bedrooms and two baths, intended for an owner-occupant. The applicant may build it or sell the lot to a builder. The Planning Commission recommended it unanimously in September 2026, and the October 12 council packet scheduled a public hearing and second reading.

Why the city keeps selling its own land

All of this traces back to a countywide shortage. The Allegan County housing initiative cited a 2023 assessment that projected a gap of more than 6,200 housing units over five years. The City of Allegan owns parcels it can offer to developers, and its recent projects reflect that. The Girl Scout property, the Lowe Street site and the North and Main lot all started as city land. In the city manager's memo, the Girl Scout plan was described as meeting the master plan's call for more housing in that area.

For buyers, that means the city's role in new housing shows up first as rentals and one-off infill, then later as a single condo and townhome community. A detached new house you can move into this year comes from one private builder on one street.

FAQ

Is River Ridge Village inside the City of Allegan? Yes. The city approved it, its address is 500 Delano Street, and the homes have Allegan addresses on North Sherman Street.

Where does the Girl Scout property project stand? The council approved the land sale in July 2025 and a lot split in December 2025. In July 2026 it approved a brownfield plan for parcels at Babylon Road, Highland Road and Wolcott Street. If you want a condo or townhome there, ask us to keep you posted as the project moves.

Will the new apartments affect resale values nearby? Street-level sales tell you more than any general rule. The Lowe Street building and the downtown units add rental housing in parts of town that are different from River Ridge Village and the Girl Scout site. When you compare resale homes near any of these projects, ask your agent for recent sales on that specific street, not the county median.

If you're deciding between a finished River Ridge house, waiting for the Girl Scout condos, or buying a resale home near downtown, Atwood Properties Group can pull recent Allegan sales and compare them against the builder's current pricing for you. If you already own in Allegan and are thinking about moving into something new, start with our instant home valuation so you know what your current house is likely to bring before you look at a new one.

Work With Us

Partner with Atwood Properties Group for expert guidance in buying, selling, renting, or investing. Honest advice, seamless service, and local expertise you can trust every step.